Jim Geraghty of National Review with Chad Benson, filling in for Greg Corombos of Radio America. In advance of the Q3 estimate, GDP appears to have hit the 3% mark. Jim and Chad discuss what this means for the average American. Next, Megan McArdle makes the case that expanding school choice has only generating minor improvement in the country’s education system. Finally, the Trump presidency may have the unfortunate side effect of encouraging reality stars with no experience in government to run for the top office.
politics
ISIS Mauled in Mosul, Comey’s Classified Memos, Donald Jr.’s Dumb Move
Jim Geraghty of National Review and Greg Corombos of Radio America celebrate the liberation of Mosul from ISIS control and the tightening of the noose around ISIS in Syria as well. They also discuss reports that former FBI Director James Comey’s memos on conversations with President Trump contain classified information. And they lightheartedly critique Donald Trump Jr.’s account of a fruitless meeting between top Trump campaign officials and a Russian lawyer who claimed to have dirt on Hillary Clinton but really wanted to talk about adoption policy.
Capitol Police Stop Shooter, Political Attack?, Polarized Media Reactions
Jim Geraghty of National Review and Rich McFadden of Radio America discuss the Capitol Police response to the shooting early Wednesday morning in Alexandria, VA where House Majority Whip Steve Scalise and others were injured during their practice for the 2017 Congressional Baseball Game. They also speculate about the possible motive of the 66-year old shooter from Illinois based on reports of his incendiary political views found on his social media account. And they react to the polarized responses on social media that are erupting across the political spectrum following the attack.
Reality Loses, Kaine’s Election Confusion, Trump’s Empty War Room
Jim Geraghty of National Review and Greg Corombos of Radio America have a field day as government contractor Reality Winner is arrested for leaking classified information to the media. They also unload on Virginia Senator Tim Kaine, who tries to leave the impression that Russia manipulated the actual vote tallies in 2016 while also admitting that there is no evidence for it. And they discuss the Trump administration’s failed attempts to assemble a war room to push back against former FBI Director James Comey’s upcoming testimony.
Trump Targets Voter Fraud
The Trump administration announced the creation of a new commission Thursday that is tasked with studying the scope of voter fraud and voter suppression in the United States, a move that a former Justice Department attorney says is long overdue after eight years of voter fraud that resembled the “wild west” during the Obama years.
The commission will be led by Vice President Mike Pence and co-chaired by Kansas Secretary of State Kris Kobach, a strong supporter of clamping down on voter fraud through measures like mandating all voters produce photo identification before casting a ballot.
Public Interest Legal Foundation President and General Counsel J. Christian Adams worked in the civil rights division of the Justice Department during the George W. Bush administration and the beginning of Obama’s first term. He says this focus is long overdue.
“We know of election crimes that have gone on in the last seven years, one after another after another, that the federal government never prosecuted and never investigated, never did anything about and creating this wild west atmosphere with voter fraudsters,” said Adams.
For examples, Adams cites Wendy Rosen, the 2012 congressional candidate in Maryland, who also voted in Florida. He says there have been over 1,000 non-citizens discovered voting in Virginia since 2011 and more than 800 others in Ohio. He says North Carolina found 41 ballots cast by non-citizens last year and Nevada found three.
Not only is the fraud not being investigated, in some cases it is celebrated.
“You have Melowese Richardson, a woman in Cincinnati, who said on camera that she voted six times for President Obama. She was actually celebrated at an event that Al Sharpton was at. They treated her like a hero,” said Adams.
The new commission is not without it’s critics however. A group called the Citizen’s Committee for Civil Rights Under Law immediately issued a statement referring to the commission’s work as “blocking the black vote.”
While the argument that voting reforms disenfranchise minorities and the poor is rather common, Adams says it is baseless.
“That narrative is a lie. More often than not, the people losing the right to vote because of election crimes are people in minority communities,” said Adams, who says his work at the Justice Department bears out his position.
“When I was at the Justice Department, I brought a case that was afflicting the minority community in a small town in Mississippi where political operatives exploited the weak and the vulnerable. They voted for them. They stole their votes. So often it is the minority communities who are being harmed by voter fraud,” said Adams.
But he didn’t stop there.
“The dirty little secret is these groups that send out these press releases like it that way, because they benefit from controlling the process. They benefit by telling people how to vote, by voting for them, by running an organization that covers up crimes, just to get certain people elected,” said Adams.
That’s why Adams suspects criticism of the commission’s work will not focus on the facts.
“The critics of the commission are essentially want to hide the facts. They don’t want us to know the truth about the extent of voter fraud. They’re accessories to the crime. If they want to cover up and obstruct the investigation into voter fraud, then those people deserve our criticism,” said Adams.
A more bipartisan criticism of the effort suggests that while voter fraud ought to be prosecuted, the problem is being blown out of proportion, After all, three votes usually don’t decide statewide elections in Nevada, 141 didn’t tilt any big races in North Carolina and even 1,000 votes would be unlikely to change results in Virginia.
Adams quickly offered two responses to that argument, starting with the crime itself.
“Changing the outcome of the election is not an element to the federal crime. That is not in the law. That is something people have invented to give people a pass and to shut down enforcement of the law,” said Adams.
But he also says voter fraud certainly can alter the outcome of elections.
“The fact that it effects elections is real. We have found at the Public Interest Legal Foundation that over 4,000 aliens have been caught on the voter rolls, many of them voting, and that’s just the tip of the iceberg. These are the ones who have self-reported essentially. So there’s tens of thousands more most likely,” said Adams.
Adams has long favored requiring voters to display photo identification at the polls and for state and local officials to regularly update voter rolls to clean out names of people who are dead or no longer live there.
He says another effective step would take very little effort.
“The easiest thing to do is to compare the voter rolls of the country to the list of aliens in federal databases. Nobody has ever done that. It’s a simple operation. It would not take very much to simply see how many people in the alien database are also registered to vote, and those who have voted should be prosecuted,” said Adams.
“It doesn’t take many prosecutions to chill criminal activity,” he added.
However, for Adams, the most important aspect of the commission may be to punch a hole in the movement of those trying to stop voting reforms.
“Those loud voices on the left have done all they can over the years to silence any examination of the vulnerabilities in our system. They have intimidated and yelled and done everything they could to hide the facts of election crimes. What they’re most upset about it that that’s ending. So I’m optimistic this is going to be a good process,” said Adams.
Three Martini Lunch 7/8/16
Rich McFadden of Radio America and Jim Geraghty of National Review grieve over the blatant targeting and murdering of police officers by a team of snipers in Dallas. They give thanks to the protesters at the Black Lives Matter demonstration in Dallas for helping police locate the snipers. And they wrestle with the question of whether rhetoric spurs violence.
Three Martini Lunch 6/27/16
Greg Corombos of Radio America and Ian Tuttle of National Review lament Monday’s Supreme Court decision striking down Texas abortion regulations. They also laugh as opponents of Brexit lose their minds over last week’s referendum. And they are exasperated at Trump’s immigration flip-flopping.
Iran Deal Already Blowing Up in Obama’s Face
The sham conviction of an American hostage in Iran, Tehran’s new testing of long-range missiles and Russian military action in Syria are all negative consequences of the U.S. joining the nuclear deal struck in July, according to Middle East and terrorism expert Dr. Walid Phares.
The latest bombshell is Iran’s announcement that a court there has convicted Washington Post reporter Jason Rezaian. The statement did not mention which charge or charges were ruled upon, offer any evidence of guilt or mention how much more time Rezaian would spend in a brutal Iranian prison.
Phares is convinced the conviction is part of Iran’s strategy to demand future concessions from the United States.
“It’s always to seek a trade, to seek an exchange. They do have some demands that we’re not aware of with regard to the United States and maybe some allied countries that they need to exchange Mr. Rezaian with these other persons,” said Phares, who is an adviser to the United States Congress on the Middle East and terrorism. He is the author most recently of “The Lost Spring.”
Phares says Iran has a long history of using hostages to get what it wants.
“The Iranian regime, since its inception in 1979 with the first hostage crisis in Tehran and again in Beirut with the Hezbollah hostage crisis, have made it very clear. On their policies, they will use hostages on major issues, not on minor issues. Now we’re experiencing this for the third time in three decades,” said Phares.
In addition to the quest for a nuclear deal with Iran, the Obama administration claimed the deal would bring Iran closer to the community of responsible nations. Phares says by giving Iran everything it wanted in the deal, it only ratcheted up the ambitions of the mullahs.
“The Iran regime for many years has showed that once they obtain what they want from the United States, then they’ll move to the second stage which is to obtain more,” said Phares. “I have been monitoring the Iranian regime’s behavior for the last 30 years, since my days in Beirut and again after the Cold War. It has a constant policy of using one stage to get to the next stage.”
And what does Iran want next?
“I’m afraid now that the Iran deal has been signed that the Iranian regime is going to build further missiles. We have the crisis yesterday and today of these new tests. Then they are going to be expanding in the region, in Iraq and Syria, now that the Russians are expanding as well,” said Phares.
According to Phares, the baseless conviction of Rezaian is further proof that the Obama administration made a major error in negotiating the nuclear deal.
“The United States administration, in my view, made a mistake for not including the liberation of all American citizens held in Iran during the Iran deal talks,” he said, suggesting the Obama team grossly miscalculated how Iran would act in the wake of the agreement.
“Now the administration realizes that the Iran regime obtained everything they wanted, including the cash which they are going to be using for buying more weapons and exerting more influence and still using the influence they obtain from the fact they have American hostages in their hands,”said Phares.
Less than a month after the U.S. Congress failed to stop American participation in the Iran nuclear deal, Phares says it is no coincidence that missile tests, show trial convictions and Russian involvement in the Middle East is unfolding now.
“Days later the Russians started to deploy into Syria. They did not want to engage in any action that would allow the United States Congress to pressure the administration not to sign or not to execute a deal,” said Phares, lamenting that the deal is already reaping the exact opposite of its intended goals
He says Syria may never regain all of its territory but we’re guaranteed to see more chaos.
“All the areas between the Turkish borders and the Lebanese borders, which are mostly alawite would now be under Russian protection. Beyond that, the Iranians are going to try to introduce forces into Syria and along the borders with Iraq. So we are heading toward more wars not less wars because of the Iran deal,” said Phares.
Mortgage Deduction Debate
As part of the debt ceiling debate, some lawmakers have suggested altering or eliminating the mortgage interest deduction, a deduction that began in 1913. Why shouldn’t it be eliminated? What is the case for taking it away? Would its removal harm the housing industry? What does it do for homeowners? Brittany Brady of Radio America has the story.
Obamacare, Immigration Both Dead
Scott Brown will be sworn in today as the new U.S. senator from Massachusetts. John Gizzi of Human Events says this one vote kills any hopes of the Democrats passing their preferred version of health care legislation. He says we won’t even see a pared-down version. Gizzi also predicts immigration reform is dead before it really even starts. He says Republicans are poised to win President Obama’s former senate seat in Illinois and also make a run at the Indiana seat held by Democrat Evan Bayh.